Woman Who Claimed RIAA Infringement Damages Were Unconstitutional Settles For $756/Song
We were a bit surprised last month when Denise Barker, who had been fighting the RIAA in a file sharing lawsuit decided to take the strategy of admitting guilt but challenging the constitutionality of the Copyright Act. That seemed like a longshot that was unlikely to play well in court -- especially a court that had already decided against her in interpreting the whole "making available" thing. So, it should come as little surprise that Barker has agreed to settle, rather than fight on, even if her lawyer, Ray Beckerman was more than willing to keep fighting.The settlement comes to $756 for each of the eight songs she's accused of sharing, and the details of the settlement work out that she'll be paying $110 per month for 55 months (running through February of 2013). That adds up to $6,050, which I imagine will put a crimp on Barker's spending on actual music. While she did break the law, and admitted to breaking the law, the punishment does seem way out of line with the "crime." It's arguable that she did any "damage" at all to the recording industry, as there's a decent chance that she actually helped promote certain artists. Permalink | Comments | Email This Story




Digg!Reddit!Del.icio.us!Facebook!Slashdot!Netscape!Technorati!StumbleUpon!Newsvine!Furl!Yahoo!Ma.gnolia!Free social bookmarking plugins and extensions for Joomla! websites!
 
< Prev   Next >

More Changes, Anyone?

Copyright © 2008 John Kolbert. Visit the original article at http://simply-basic.com/general/more-changes-anyone/.
Anyone who’s followed me for any period of time knows that I like to change Simply-Basic’s appearance…     Readmore

Thoughts for the Week

Copyright © 2008 John Kolbert. Visit the original article at http://simply-basic.com/general/thoughts-for-the-week/.
Well another week down, and what a week it has been! Not only has it been busy…     Readmore

WP Advanced Code Editor

Copyright © 2008 John Kolbert. Visit the original article at http://simply-basic.com/announcements/wp-advanced-code-editor/.
For those interested, I wrote a plugin for Techlyzer.com that was just released. It’s called     Readmore

Check Out My Other Home: Techlyzer.com

Copyright © 2008 John Kolbert. Visit the original article at http://simply-basic.com/general/check-out-my-other-home-techlyzercom/.
Hi all. I’m happy to announce the launch of a new website that I’ll be trying to…     Readmore

Gadget Advisor Blog

Copyright © 2008 John Kolbert. Visit the original article at http://simply-basic.com/reviews/gadget-advisor-blog/.
Being a tech-centric blog I’m always on the lookout for other technology related websites. For those with…     Readmore

Updates to Permalinks

Copyright © 2008 John Kolbert. Visit the original article at http://simply-basic.com/announcements/updates-to-permalinks/.
After a lot of deliberation I’ve changed the permalink structure of Simply-Basic. When I started the blog…     Readmore

Qwest Web.Help: Stop Hijacking My Browser (How to Opt-Out)

Copyright © 2008 John Kolbert. Visit the original article at http://simply-basic.com/posts/1941493.
Earlier today I was surfing the web and mistyped a URL. Rather then getting the customary “The…     Readmore

Change Default File Type and Path for Screen Captures [Mac Tips]

Copyright © 2008 John Kolbert. Visit the original article at http://simply-basic.com/posts/1941482.
Mac only - I frequently use Mac’s built in screen capture ability to create the images you…     Readmore

Coming Soon: Comment on Lifehacker Using Your Facebook ID

Copyright © 2008 John Kolbert. Visit the original article at http://simply-basic.com/posts/1941478.
I just noticed that Lifehacker is joining the ranks of sites using the new Facebook Connect,…     Readmore

dealdotcom
Earn $$ with WidgetBucks!